Secularism means keeping religion in the personal sphere and justice in the public domain: Julio Ribeiro

December 1, 2014    

'Supercop' Julio F Ribeiro, former DGP Punjab and Commissioner of Police, Bombay speaks to Teesta Setalvad about the challenges of tackling terroir, the importance of promoting communal harmony and the urgent need for police reform. Listen in to this special interview of Communalism Combat.




Super Cop Julio Ribeiro on Operation Black thunder, KPS Gill and
Akali Party- Part 1
Super Cop on how Judiciary told him not to bring the militants in front of them. PART 2
Super Cop Julio Ribeiro on Mohalla Committee and on Police leadership must be egalitarian - Part 3
Super Cop says religion is personal. In Public space there should be Justice and equality- Part 4
Super Cop- Empower the Police Force Leaders to fight corruption. Appoint the right Leader. - Part 5
Gujarat is a good example that if Police Officers were in charge the riots were avoidable- Part 6
Death Penalty won't solve rape cases. Female Foeticide has to be stopped- Part 7

The challenge of dealing with terrorism is like none other since everything is on the side of the terrorist, ‘Super Cop” Julio Ribeiro, former Director General of Police, Punjab told Communalism Combat and Hillele TV in a special interview. Author of Bullet for Bullet that accounts the years tackling militant insurgency in the Punjab, Ribeiro spoke of how the entire system was in a sense terrorized or frightened into dysfunctionality. Recounting his experiences during his tenure in Punjab first as DGP and then as Advisor to the Governor, Ribeiro in this interview to Teesta Setalvad spoke of how out of the box efforts had to be made to reach out to villagers to wean away the terror and influence of the gun. “ I know that in my time, Jat Sikhs from several villages came to me and said they were not in support of the terror”, said Ribeiro and hence Operation Black Thunder was handled differently from Bluestar.

Terrorists do not care for the state, the rules that govern the state, they do not bribe cops like the underworld does, they shoot them. Explaining how in the most open and shut cases too, the judiciary let off the militants, the octogenarian policeman who remains a conscience keeper for the Mumbai police force explained how he had long discussions even with the Judiciary. The reaction of Judges was, ‘don’t bring these terrorists before us!” and hence the blame cannot rest only on the policeman. The lives of several judges were lost during the days of militancy.

On the issue of communalism and the politics of hatred, Julio Ribeiro was of the firm opinion that India’s electoral system, first past the post, facilitates the appeal for votes on the basis of religion or caste causing divisions within society. “We must reform the system so that candidates who get over 50 per cent of the votes polled have a face off; and are forced to seek support of one and all not just the one section as is happing now,” said Ribeiro. Besides the leadership of the Indian Police Service (IPS) needs to be trained to be egalitarian and non-discriminatory, to give meaning to the fundamentals of the Indian Constitution.

Secularism for me means keeping religion in the personal sphere and the principles goodness and justice in the public domain. Ribeiro has been active on issues related to the promotion of communal harmony through the Bombay Mohalla Committee Trust that he launched along with fellow travelers FT Khorakhiwala, former Commissioner of Police, Bombay, Satish Sahney and activist Sushobha Barve. He has also been a vocal spokesperson for reforms within the Indian Police Force.

The senior policeman also spoke against the Death Penalty which he says is never a solution to any crime and has never been. To the young man or woman who aspires to join the Police Force Ribeiro’s words of advise were” Join only if you want to serve, if you can deliver justice to the people. People will stand by you if you deliver justice. Then only will you have people on your side.”


Other reading Materials:

1.     Who Is to Blame? Communalism Combat See

2.     Report of the Ribeiro Committee (Critique)

3.     Police Reforms in India

4.     Mumbai gang-rape: Bombay was safe. Is Mumbai safe?, asks former Mumbai Police chief Julio Ribeiro

5.     Tiger Bal Thackeray dreaded the cage, cops the Tiger

6.     What really happened at Azad Maidan on August 11?

7.     Ready for reform

8.     Muslim IPS officers isolated: Ribeiro

9.     Julio Ribeiro versus K.P.S. Gill  NA, May 27, 2002 (
"Gill can solve the Gujarat problem in a week but he will have to arrest VHP members and Muslim criminals. If Modi allows that, he will be signing his own death warrant."
Julio Ribeiro Former Punjab Police chief