Frontline
July 1999
Newscan

Left will have no truck with saffron
West Bengal chief minister, Jyoti Basu created waves when he refused to travel with Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee on the inaugural run of the Calcutta–Dhaka bus on June 19 calling the BJP a "barbaric" party. Arriving a day earlier, Basu was not present at the reception for the Indian PM at the airport. Not only that, the Bengali "son of the soil" captured Bangladeshi hearts and received a rousing reception eclipsing Vajpayee’s presence, much to the chagrin of the Centre. Speeches made by both Basu and Bangladeshi Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina were in Bengali and local authorities, aided by Basu, lost no opportunity in playing up his birth–place, Dhaka. Sheikh Hasina even invited the Banglababu for a private reception, a favour that was not extended to the Indian Prime Minister.

To Jyoti Basu goes the credit of easing relationships with our neighbour in the east including the Centre’s historic water sharing treaty, signed during Prime Minister Deve Gowda’s tenure. Meanwhile, the BJP government, is currently facing biting criticism for refusing well–known writer, Sunil Gangopadhyaya a visa for the journey, allegedly because he has been encouraging separatism in the north–east.

Centre silent on Wadhwa report
The Justice D.P. Wadhwa Commission which probed the killing of Australian missionary Graham Steines and his two minor sons on January 23 this year submitted its 250–page report to the Union home secretary, Kamal Pande, on June 21. Details of the findings and conclusions arrived at by the investigation were not revealed since the criminal investigations in the case were still being concluded.

Justice D.P.Wadhwa, however, in a public statement, described the incident as an "entirely unjustified act which is a slur on humanity and a blot on civilised society."

The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), on June 22, 1999 filed a charge–sheet against 18 persons, including prime suspect Dara Singh in connection with the brutal murder, by burning, of Graham Staines, an Australian social worker and his two young sons at Manoharpur in the Keonjhar district of Orissa on January 23, 1999. Staines and his sons were burnt to death while they were asleep inside a vehicle at the height of the anti–Christian hysteria whipped up by the sangh parivar, especially the RSS, VHP and the Bajrang Dal in the states of Gujarat, Orissa, Madhya Pradesh and Delhi (see CC, October 1998, January 1999 and June 1999). Mahanta, one of the 18 persons charge–sheeted by the CBI, was arrested by a special squad of the the Keonjhar police at Duburi in Jajpur on June 30. Dara Singh, the main accused has not been apprehended by the authorities six months after the brutal murder of Steines.

The CBI filed the charge–sheet in the court of the designated magistrate, E.Vasudev Rao, nearly three months after it started probing the case. The state government had asked the agency to investigate the case after the police failed to make much progress. Meanwhile, the Orissa police have lodged a criminal case against Binoy Bhusan Patnaik, the photo journalist who interviewed Dara Singh, main accused in the killings of Australian missionary Graham Staines and his two minor sons in Manoharpur village of Keonjhar district. The case has been registered under section 212 and 216 of IPC against Patnaik for allegedly harbouring and concealing Dara in a place known to him.

According to the FIR lodged by Keonjhar district police, Patnaik was aware of the involvement of Dara Singh in the Staines murder, the eight other criminal cases pending against him, as also the state government’s proclamation that Singh was an offender with a cash reward of Rs. one lakh on his head. But still, Patnaik harboured the criminal with the intention to prevent him from being apprehended, it said. Meanwhile, the photo–journalist, who was arrested on July 3 and released on bail later, told newsmen here that he was being harassed by the police.

Patnaik claimed that he had agreed to lead the police to the spot on the Judia hills, about five kilometres from Keonjhar town, where he had accidentally met Dara Singh on March 12 last and interviewed him provided he and his family members were assured of personal safety. However, the police have denied this. The interview of Dara Singh by Binoy Patnaik telecast on a private TV channel on the night of March 29 last had caused a sensation all over the country.

Muslim students’ ‘hat-trick’ in Maharashtra
For the third year running, a Muslim student from Maharashtra’s Urdu medium schools has topped from one of the state secondary school examination board’s this year. Pune city’s Bilal Iqbal Mistry, from the Anglo Urdu Boys High School Pune, topped the state school examinations obtaining 96.53 per cent marks. In 1997 and 1998, Maharashtra’s Tanveer Maniar and Zarine Ansari respectively obtained kudos making this year’s achievemnt a ‘hat–trick’ for the community. A total of 11,080 students appeared in the Urdu medium for the examinations this year of which 10,505 passed in 1999.

What is most significant about this, however, is the silence with which these achievements have been received by the national English medium press that is quick to transmit news that portrays India’s largest minority in a negative right. When such obvious examples of progress and ‘main–streaming’ among Muslims are borne out by events, no news reports or editorials are penned.

These facts came up for stringent criticism from Mumbai’s largest circulating daily, Inquilab. In a strongly worded editorial, the paper wrote: "Our complaint with the English press (except the Mid–Day that carried a story) is that only the negative news about Muslims is considered news. If a Muslim youth is caught with drugs it makes front–page news, or if a Muslim youth is involved in a crime or divorce… But when, among the same Muslim boys a Tanveer or Bilal comes out from behind closed doors, and tops his school or college, the English press is smitten into silence! The reporters from the English newspapers who promised to cover the felicitation function for Tanveer Maniar in 1997 are still to make it to the venue!"

ISI threat or minority– bashing?
The discovery of unexploded bombs at Chennai, Coimbatore and Tiruchi (on May 30) and the subsequent investigations have led to a controversy with former chief minister and general secretary of the AIDMK, Jayalalitha accusing the DMK government of using the occasion to launch a terror campiagn against the state’s minorities. In a series of statements she also voiced suspicion about the motives of those responsible for planting the bombs. "In the context of the minorities aligning with the opposition front against Mr. Karunanidhi, is it possible that some mischief makers are behind the bomb plots to bring disrepute to the Muslim minority community?’’ she wondered.

Meanwhile, The CB–CID has arrested two more activists of the banned Al Umma in connection with the planting of bombs in Coimbatore and identified those responsible for placing the explosive devices in Chennai and Tiruchi. Security was also tightened around Mettur Dam, the lifeline of the agrarian economy of Kerala following the developments around Kargil. The detention of two persons, Sheikh Mohammad Ummar, Shah alias Raju (30) and Jaleel alias Abdul Jaleel (18), both residing at Coimbatore, were in addition to the four Al Umma extremists already held by the police. The enquiries, according to the authorities, had also shown that one Zakir Hussain who is eluding the police dragnet was the "brain behind all the unexploded bombs in Coimbatore, Tiruchi and Chennai and also in the Coimbatore serial blasts last year’’.

The Kerala unit of the CPI(M) has, meanwhile, demanded a white paper on the activities of extremist and terrorist groups from the government.

Sectarian violence in Mumbai
In a re-play of the sectarian violence between two rival Sunni sects, the Deobandhis and Barelvis, that took lives in Mumbai last year, this year’s Id–e–Milad celebrations were also marred with violence that culminated in the death of a maulvi on June 27. Seventy–two–years–old Haji Abdul Qadeer died inside the Jameel Masjid at Madanpura on that day to a sectarian dispute that assumed violent overtones.

According to the deputy police commissioner, Venkateshan, the dispute between the two sects this time was around whether or not visitors from other towns in India be allowed to rest within the precincts of the mosques or not. It had been resolved at an earlier meeting that Indians visiting from other parts should not be allowed to stay. But on June 27 a meeting was called to discuss the issue once again, at which the earlier decision was reiterated. However, after the afternoon prayers, a violent disagreement around the decision ensued and during the scuffle, the Haji was killed. Of the eight persons arrested by the police, one Ansari Mohammed Raza, the main accused in the murder, has a criminal record.

Meanwhile the city’s Urdu press, among them the widely read Inquilab, unequivocally condemned this sectarian violence and its violent dimensions. "It is only when a non–Muslim plays music outside a mosque or throws gulal at the mosque that our feelings are aroused because we consider this an assault on the dignity of the mosque. We are then willing to be killed and kill in the cause; hundreds of riots have broken out all over the country over this. But where is the dignity of the mosque when one Muslim slays his worshipping brother within its precincts?"

Pakistan Hindus refuse to go back
Over 1,000 "Hindus" belonging to the Bheel and Bawaria tribes from Bhawalpur in Pakistan, who arrived in two batches on temporary visas and have been staying since at Sirsa in Haryana, have refused to go back. They have alleged harassment due to "religious intolerance" in Pakistan. 477 Pakistani Hindus have been living in this district for the past two–six years and another batch of 550 more arrivd last month.

Referring to their plight, former Union minister for human resources development, Uma Bharati, told a private television channel, "If one crore Bangladeshis and a large number of people belonging to other nationalities could live unauthorisedly in India, why should these unfortunate people be forced to go back?"


[ Subscribe | Contact Us | Archives | Khoj | Aman ]
[ Letter to editor  ]
Copyrights © 2001, Sabrang Communications & Publishing Pvt. Ltd.